John Davis posted a comment on Saturday 18th August 2007 3:22pm for Life, Death, & Quidditch

interesting
thought you were going to tell Dumbles there for a second. wish he had it would have made for an even more interesting discussion
keep up the good work
I love this story

Ken Warner posted a comment on Saturday 18th August 2007 2:54pm for Life, Death, & Quidditch

Excellent and most enjoyable, despite the tragic murder of a good slytherin. I thought that the confrontation between neville and his grandmother was masterful, thanks much for that.

I await anxiously each new chapter, and really hope that you will not spend much effort trying to make your story match DH canon.

warm regards

Seritha posted a comment on Saturday 18th August 2007 2:36pm for Life, Death, & Quidditch

Yes UPDATE! whoa that was good, I have to say that this is coming along splendidly that was so sad about her sister but I hope that whoever did it gets payback.

Antosha posted a comment on Saturday 18th August 2007 2:34pm for Life, Death, & Quidditch

It's wonderful to see this tale continue—new canon or not, its internal logic is a pleasure to behold.

Neville standing up to his grandmother was particularly wonderful.

I look forward to seeing this fic grow!

Teresa Lynne posted a comment on Saturday 18th August 2007 2:29pm for Life, Death, & Quidditch

An excellent chapter! Both Neville and Harry acted with honor and I look forward to seeing how their actions play out. Sigh..... it's too bad that Melissa died during that attack on Harry. Harry has been concerned that his changes to the timeline have caused situations to take a nastier turn but it's equally possible that similar situations would have occured the first time if Voldemort and his minions had been faced strongly. Voldemort and company didn't have to exert themselves as quickly or as much in the first timeline since they had people like Fudge and Umbridge to stir things up outside of Hogwarts, and Snape and Draco on the inside. It is possible that what seemed to be a passive allience in the first timeline between the Ministry and the Death Eaters has become a stronger one now......but then, there was a tendency towards that sort of thing in any case. Umbridge being a case in point. Perhaps Dumbledore might consider Harry's words about why he and his friends have trained so much, and why; as well as their discussion after Melissa's death. Many thanks to you, and as always I look forward to the next chapter!

MrRobertsIII posted a comment on Saturday 18th August 2007 2:13pm for Life, Death, & Quidditch

Excellent twist with Melissa. Never saw that coming. Her father's not going after the killers was rather chilling.

Thanks for keeping this fic going.

pri_yes posted a comment on Saturday 18th August 2007 2:02pm for Life, Death, & Quidditch

Thank you so much! It was the highlight of my day, keep it up.

BT posted a comment on Saturday 18th August 2007 1:52pm for Life, Death, & Quidditch

Oh my, so glad you updated!

Neville is awesome in both this story and DH.

Dragnew posted a comment on Saturday 18th August 2007 1:21pm for Life, Death, & Quidditch

Fantastic, as always.
I look forward to future updates.

vl100butch posted a comment on Saturday 18th August 2007 12:38pm for Life, Death, & Quidditch

Been a long but worthwhile wait for this chapter